68

Editorial: Is the mad drive towards super-user-friendliness killing console gaming?

vaga_koleso | May 28, 2008 | Blog | Misc 
Is the drive to make console games excessively "user-friendly" stifling developer creativity, insulting the intelligence of gamers, and forcing games to evolve into little more than (barely) interactive movies? One could conceivably make a stand on either side of this argument - where do you make yours?
Game developers must always tread a fine line between their artistic vision and the reality of what makes a good game as opposed to a desktop science experiment. Sure, the idea of an ultra-detailed space sim (for example) where you can literally control every aspect of the game might sound great in theory (just like Communism or car jousting); in practice, unfortunately, you might wind up with Battlecruiser 3000AD: A Derek Smart Pile of Steaming Monkey Feces, or whatever that bug-ridden mess was actually called. Games must remain games, but in the last 5-7 years there has been a growing dichotomy between how developers and marketing departments define what that really means. While developers realize that there are certain consumer accessibility requirements that games must meet, they also generally assume that their games can nonetheless exhibit a certain degree of complexity. Marketing departments, on the other hand, come from a long history of treating consumers of video games like 10-year old children, despite the fact that the demographics of this particular market have long moved into much more mature age groups.
2 comments | go to source (www.gamelemon.com) | Add to favorites! favourite this article | send to friend | add alt source
Register as a member to subscribe comments.

Comments with -10 or lower "thumbs" are removed from display.

  • 0 thumbs!
    Benedict | May 29, 2008
    This article is hard to understand.

    Gaming - Well, its not killing anyone and it never has. I don't want to be the first though.
  • 1 thumbs!
    JayCat | May 29, 2008
    It's a tough balance. I'm the "typical" console gamer that you mentioned: I have a husband, a kid, a full time job. So, one the one hand: I'm not a dummy, so I don't mind complex games. On the other hand, I just want to pick up and PLAY. I don't necessarily want to be frustrated the game I play. Again, there is a balance: tough enough to challenge, easy enough so that I don't throw my controller through the TV.

    But I do agree. I was very surprised at people's reviews for FF: Crisis Core. Everything is basically controlled by a random number generator, so you have VERY little control. But because it's FF (and I do enjoy the franchise) somehow people forget gameplay, and how important it is.

This news story is archived and is closed to comments now.

Submit Newshelp

Top Contributors

This Month
Twisted 294 pts
Tyranitar24 251 pts
chautemoc 210 pts
Gothic Girl 202 pts
Cruxis Mana 198 pts
Akira_EX 172 pts
Dark Arcan.. 151 pts
Deathsythe 137 pts
Linkin Par.. 135 pts
SuperGuido 119 pts
All-Time
Gothic Girl 18434 pts
Krunal 12307 pts
Linkin Par.. 10379 pts
chautemoc 9741 pts
Final Blade 9209 pts
Silver Mir.. 8843 pts
xsynergyx 7909 pts
Akira_EX 7813 pts
mistermostyn 7668 pts
Tyranitar24 7044 pts

Stats

Today
Published News: 29
Comments: 147
Points Given: 356
Users Registered: 6
This Month
Published News: 133
Comments: 781
Points Given: 1712
Users Registered: 12
All Time
Published News: 11140
Comments: 76108
Points Given: 179998
Users Registered: 582

Conventions / Trade Shows

(0.1295/d/aeon)