With today's gamer requiring a fast paced, highly action oriented, and not all that thought provoking game - it is no wonder we have seen the decline of traditional point and click RPGs like most of us grew up with back in the day. I enjoyed spending literally days of my life playing these games, maxing out stats, collecting every secret - no matter how pointless, and growing pale in my basement with my only source of light being the television and and power button for weeks on end.

LordChandar of Gamespot takes a look at the rise of the MMO, and other factors that led to the downfall of our beloved genre.

Call me old school, but I grew up with traditional RPG games like Ultima and Might 'n' Magic on the PC and Final Fantasy/Dragon Warrior on the NES and SNES. I understand that technology has to evolve, but why does the gameplay have to be thrown out the window? Why does the feel of an RPG have to be so 'cold' now? Why is it that with the advent of 3D technology all games, RPGs especially now have to be 'ultra-realistic'? RPGs are based in FANTASY. Games are meant to be challenging and fun. Games like Elder Scrolls are wonderful to look at, and they are nice to roam around in, but they are too encumbered and too difficult and realistic to be 'any fun.'

Games like Diablo and Dungeon Siege occasionally help to try and fill the void, but these games are way too few and far between these days. All RPGs now almost seem to have to automatically be MMO only. Games like WoW are why Blzzard was able to wait so long to finally even create Diablo III. Creating MMOs are ideal for companies because they don't have to create a lengthy, captivating story line, or put ton's of stuff for one person or a very small group of people to do. The world doesn't have to be as balanced, and they can basically throw it together very quickly, get it out the door in no time, and then sit back and collect out $9.95 or $12.95 or however much you MMO of choice charges.

MMOs are a very important part of gaming today. They should not be replaced, but they are NOT a replacement for true traditional RPGs either. We need RPGS that have great single or multi-player capability, wonderful story lines, and great things to do in the game. I would gladly pay $60+ for a game I can play by myself or with a small group of people (battleNet) and that has tons of replay value...

To all the game manufacturers who make RPGs or used to make RPGs: Please start making good, deep, single player RPGs again. RPGs that we can become emotionally involved in. RPGs that have tons of replay value. RPGs we can lose months of social life to if we so choose.
| More
Images about this story:
Latest comment:
Most recently commented on by on Jul 1, 2008
Register as a member to subscribe comments.
  • 2
    chautemoc Jun 30, 08
    Loved your description.
    Cool you used a gamer's blog post too..not too often stuff like that is grabbed up. Good stuff.

    I agree with the writer and it's something I've been thinking about lately..something has been lost in most RPGs today..there are a few keeping the feel alive (Etrian Odyssey comes to mind)..but mostly its gone and seems to have kind of died since the 7th generation came about..sad.

    I dont think I agree about MMOs though..they seem just as challenging if not moreso to make, just in a different way. I imagine they're very hard to finish, but once they are it's a breeze, and benefits the creators for a very long time (assuming the game does okay).
  • 1
    huntyr Jun 30, 08
    If you actually "Finish" a MMO, then you've done something unexpected. MMOs are designed to be endless time sinks with no real way to finish them
  • 2
    kspiess Jun 30, 08
    Hrmm I'm torn on this subject. Modern RPG's definitely seem less RPG-ish than they used to be, if that makes sense.

    As for the combat though, I think the more action-centric combat of today's RPGS is more fun, in many cases. Like Mass Effect for example.

    It is definitely definitely harder to find RPGS that have as complex and advanced character systems as found in the old games though. Like in Fallout 2, there was an amazing amount of skills and stats and such... modern RPGs are often far more simpler, to the determinant of the game.

    Like Fallout 3 will probably be much more of an action RPG than a real RPG unfortunately. Because graphics are so important these days developers don't think it is a priority to make a RPG as complex as they were... there is exceptions though, I guess.
  • 1
    McClubbin Jun 30, 08
    It's a shame really, that they've shifted away from traditional RPGs. I grew up at a time when Final Fantasy, Chrono Trigger, and the like were some of the most popular games of the era. They hold a lot of nostalgia and I wish developers would go back and try to make an old school RPG once in a while. The only real RPG that I've got my hopes pegged on is Archaic Sealed Heat, or ASH for short, for the DS which seems to combine traditional and modern RPG elements.
    • 1
      chautemoc Jun 30, 08
      Looking forward to ASH, too.
      • 1
        McClubbin Jul 1, 08
        Wow, somebody else who's heard about ASH besides me. The game seems amazing, but it's a shame it was received so poorly in Japan. I just hope they don't decide to stop the localization process fearing that it does poorly internationally.
  • 2
    Zeon I Jun 30, 08
    I agree with this article 100%. Recently, I've started playing classic RPGs, and I must say, I like them more than the ones we have today. Too bad getting a hand on an old RPG Games is damn near impossible these days, which makes you turn to emulation (which is bad). They're so popular and legendary people think they can sell them for ridiculously high prices. Newsflash, You can't.

    Most RPG Characters today are Paper Thin and have absolutely no depth to them. Most old characters are complex and the story actually makes you feel like you're the only one who can save the world. Also, the old game's plots don't focus around love and put saving the world second, something newer games are a culprit of.

    Boss Battles are no longer complex. Most people today seem to think that having an ASSLOAD of HP can replace genuine Difficulty. It doesn't. It just makes the Battle more longer and unnecessary.

    Also, I'm not a big fan of MMO's. The worlds are way too big for my liking and you can easily wander into a difficult area and be punished for it. Plus, most people are assholes.
  • 0
    kik36 Jun 30, 08
    Personally I'm receptive to both and enjoy elements from both....but not necessarily combined.
  • 1
    Jaw Knee Jul 1, 08
    This is one of the video game genres that is constantly being thrown carelessly into oblivion.
  • 0
    Demonfurby Jul 1, 08
    quote
    This is one of the video game genres that is constantly being thrown carelessly into oblivion.
    QFT
  • 0
    Bale Fire Jul 1, 08
    Action RPG's do seem to be all the rage these days, but personally I never understood why everyone hated the old setup with random encounters and turn based fight all that much in the first place. Nothing wrong with them from my perspective.
  • 0
    Agrias Jul 1, 08
    Nice and inspiring. It surely brings back Old memories. Of course we all enjoyed playing those games such as Final Fantasy origins, however I used to get so mad. I was always getting lost and not knowing what to do, and the battles were so repetitive. Yet, those games served as an example to correct previous mistakes; thanks to those games, great productions have been released in the past, lets see...2 years.

This news story is archived and is closed to comments now.