I know of many people that own the Wii and love it like no other console and on the other hand, I also know quite a few people that own a PS3 or a XBOX360 who equally love the console. Whilst PS3 and XBOX360 are at each others throats (especially the Fanboys), there is one thing that MANY (not all) will agree on - the Wii is not in the competition because it's not a true gamers console, and whilst many Wii Fanboys would disagree with that, this is one of the few points in the console war that I agree on.

The Wii to me is not a gaming console, it doesn't have a steady steam of good quality games that I'd like to play. It has a huge number of games available yes, but only a mere handful of them interest me. In fact, I'm probably more interested in more XBOX360 games than I am Wii games. But the main question of the article is - Is Nintendo Digging its Own Grave?

They've released great games such as Zelda, Super Mario Galaxy (also known for it's "U R MY GAY" reference) and Metroid to name a few, however E3 came, and went and gamers were severely disappointed with the whole keynotes speech. It even made itself onto Kotaku's "Things we never want to see again at E3". Are Nintendo simply alienating their game-loving audience?

In essence, this article asks the question of whether or not Nintendo are digging their own grave or not. So be sure to read through the source and tell us if you agree or not.

Also be sure to watch the video at the end of the third page for some highlights from the E3 Keynotes speech (fairly old video... but a good laugh... unless you're Sonic Flash)

We’re gamers. We just want to get that clear right off the bat. If you happen to be a sixty year old grandma who’s dedicated to at least one Wii Fit session a day and loves Nintendo’s little white box more than a box of Cadbury’s favourites then we’re not talking to you. We’re talking to those of you who went and bought a high-definition TV to enhance your gaming experience.
| More
News story attached to:
Latest comment:
Most recently commented on by on Oct 8, 2008
Register as a member to subscribe comments.
  • 0
    Dark Arcanine Oct 3, 08
    I love the main picture. OMG at the bad grammar (fairly old video... but a good laugh... unless your Sonic Flash) jokes.

    I don't know about dying, but the list of games is certainly thinning. I think the Wii does sell very well but not so well in the games itself. Doesn't mean to say the Wii won't get more winners in the future and the popular games selling really well isn't going to stop.

    As for the casual gaming thing sort of popping into there again, offering something different to the competition can only do you good.
    • 1
      Krunal Oct 3, 08
      Bah... it got lost in translation... from uhh.. my english to everyones english

  • 0
    Krunal Oct 3, 08
    I just want to get this out of the way - I do agree wholeheartedly with the article. As a gamer, I'm really enjoying playing R:FoM, Uncharted and Warhawk, all three of which I couldn't have been enjoying as much if I was playing on the Wii (I should mention I'm also lazy, so any game that requires me to not be lazy, and move my hands in the fashion shown in the video... well lets just put it this way... I'm not going to be doing it).

    Personally speaking, I know a few people who have a Wii, they all bought games for it on release, and they've not really gotten any new games recently. Simply put they're not gamers. If it's a party, they'll play one of their already owned games rather than getting a new party game just for it... The gamers that I know that own a Wii use to go on about playing Zelda and/or metroid, but recently I've heard little to nothing from them... and this article makes me think that it's a simple case of them just not making sequels for the games that matter the most.
  • 0
    Dark Arcanine Oct 3, 08
    Ah I see, your advanced vocabulary enthralls me to the point I must learn it.

    Would you be saying it's more of a home entertainment appliance than a gaming one? In that respect I would agree with you because I think a lot of people treat it as such.

    It all started with the Wii Remote if you ask me.
    • 0
      Krunal Oct 3, 08
      Actually, I wouldn't even think it's much of home entertainment system... for me the only times I've ever wanted to play the Wii is when there's a party going on. Outside of that, it's just not been as inviting... oh with the exception of SSBB, I really did want to play that...

      I think my PS3 is more of a home entertainment system than anything else... it has a massive harddrive to house my favourite films (Don't Mess with the Zohan, Harold & Kumar: Escape Guantamano Bay, Transformers etc...) and that's me naming only some english ones.

      And you're right, it did all start with the Wii Remote. Without the Wii Remote, you literally have nothing... but that said, the Wii Remote has made the console, and that is a great thing, but I'd rather they let the games make the console. Good games + Wii Remote could mean that they could actually "enter the console war, and win it by a mile".
  • 0
    Dark Arcanine Oct 3, 08
    I'm with you on that one about the combination of the Wii Remote and games, they really need to find a sense of equilibrium there.

    The new Nintendo Wii, currently really speculation, which I covered suggests that the Wii will too move into memory storage and whatnot and probably will be able to dive into the realm of music and films quite nicely.

    Perhaps the speculated "HD Nintendo Wii" is Nintendo's answer to the first sort of failed version? Despite the fact the release wouldn't be for years due to constant sales.
    • 0
      Krunal Oct 3, 08
      The first version hasn't failed, long from it. It's just not been as big a success as it could have been if it had kept to the core gamer audience as well as the non-gamer audience. Had two different types of controllers maybe, allow the gamers to play with the normal controller, and non-gamers the other one.

      Though I guess all these things would increase the price of the Wii making it unsuitable to non-gamers...
  • 3
    Absolute Oct 3, 08
    I agree 100%, to me the Wii is more of a social machine than a real gaming console.

    For example: when I'm alone, I will always play either Mass Effect, CoD4, Halo 3, Uncharted, etc. But when I have a party, or basically when alot of my friends who are not gamers, or even computer-literate come over. They never want to play any real games on my 360 or PS3. But then I pull the Wii out from under my bed, (yeah, I don't play it at all, so I would rather have it out of the way). Everyone jumps at the chance to play it.

    So basically, Wii+Hardcore gamer=Boredom, Wii+hardcore gamer+friends who don't like video games=fun.

    My 2 cents.
  • 0
    Daigoji_Gai Oct 3, 08
    Anyone that thinks Nintendo is digging their own grave doesn't understand and really never understood the Nintendo business model.

    They are doing gangbusters right now by catering the mainstream (not hardcore) audience, and the fact that the Wii is being used in fitness programs, geriatric care facilities, hospitals, and schools proves their model is exceeding in a more widespread gaming industry.

    They know what they are doing, been around for a very long time, and while we (hard core) may not agree with their business direction - they aren't being hurt by catering to this wider audience... in fact they are doign better.
    • 3
      Krunal Oct 3, 08
      But how many games do you think this "non-hardcore" audiences are buying every year? My friends have bought 2-3 games in the past year for the console and relied mostly on the party games that came with it...
      • 0
        Daigoji_Gai Oct 3, 08
        Not many Krunal, and that is a great point. They are looking at achieving something similar to what the PS2 achieved, worldwide console infiltration in as many households as possible.

        If you look at what they are doing with their upcoming lineup they are really focusing on increasing their library of "group oriented" and party games - case in point that Wii Music game debuted at E3.

        Unlike the PS2 (as you pointed out) they still face the problem of a lack of "must have" software. With the PS2, even though it was in more households than any other console, there was a seriously library to support it, and PS2 owners were willing (if not with every release) to continue to try and buy new games for the console... Like you pointed out, even people I know with Wii that aren't gamers really aren't jumping with excitement that something like Mad World is coming out... or are even aware of many of the upcoming releases like the Resident Evil remake...

        Great point.
        • 4
          Fatal Error Oct 4, 08
          You're full of shit with this whole "Nintendo business model" thing. I keep seeing people say that, but all it ends up being is a bunch of BS about making excuses over why Nintendo is alienating people like none other.
  • 0
    sonyandnintendorule Oct 3, 08
    personally i think nintendo gonna get as big of an audience as it can then try to slowly blend together hardcore and casual gamers
  • 0
    Big A2 Oct 3, 08
    So what these people are saying is, that if Nintendo keeps going the way they are, then they won't make a new console untill almost everyone on the plannet owns one.

    And I agree with them.

    OH I KNOW, I should make a time machine and go back to the 80's and warn Nintendo about how pissed of people will be about the Wii. I might also tell them not to be stupid when advertising EarthBound.
  • 0
    Killosity Oct 3, 08
    quote
    personally i think nintendo gonna get as big of an audience as it can then try to slowly blend together hardcore and casual gamers
    Exactly. Shovelware aside, brand loyalty amongst the uneducated of gamer will grow and Nintendo will start to push more hardcore games.
    • 2
      BlackLabel Oct 3, 08
      Though thats the problem Nintendo seem to be missing that the casual and the hardcore gamer on the Wii are just not buying games, even if a hardcore game slapped a casual gamer in the face they wouldn't buy it because they are just not gamers, most of the Wii's fanbase is built on people that bought it as a cheap toy and thats going to hit Nintendo very hard when they come to upgrade their console, i say this as if the casual won't buy games then they won't buy the Wii 2 lol.
      • 2
        Big A2 Oct 4, 08
        Please stop calling it the Wii 2. If anything we don't want another Wii.
        • 0
          Krunal Oct 5, 08
          How about calling it the "Nintendo Revolution"? If it's not another Wii, it may very well be the much awaited Nintendo Revolution
        • 0
          Final Blade Oct 6, 08
          Big A2, you honestly think its not going to be called Wii 2? Sorry thats stupid. They're creating a shit load on money with the name as it is, they're not going to call it something else.

          I doubt that Krunal, as I said the Wii name has made a shit load of money. Whether they're digging their own grave, not calling it a Wii 2 is stupid.

          Also its not the name thats making the system bad, its the shovelware.
        • 0
          Big A2 Oct 7, 08
          I never said anything about the name, I was talking about the approach of the consonle. If they make a normal console like the PS3 or 360, and still call it Wii 2, I'd be fine with that.
  • 0
    Gamesta100 Oct 4, 08
    Sadly I think Ninty are doing the best that ever have.

    No I don't mean it in the way some of you may think.I like Ninty and it's good they are doing well.But I feel they are doing well for the wrong reason.Casual gamers.They care WAY to much about all their casual gamers and not their hardcore gamers.Now that may be working tremendously for them but for the gaming industry as a whole, I think they are ruining it.

    I think the reason a lot of developers are making so many games these days user friendly and making them easier, is because they see how well Ninty are doing buy making such games.

    I would love a concrete reason to buy a Wii but I see very little reason to buy a Wii.Even if I did, I would spend most of my time playing the old games rather than Wii games.

    Personally I think the DS is more fun than a Wii would be.Hell I'm loving playing FF4 on DS which I find to be REALLY hard at times.

    Feel free to prove me wrong as I don't like thinking that Ninty is ruining the gaming industry.
  • 0
    Final Blade Oct 4, 08
    I pretty much agree with the article 100%.

    I grew up playing the great games on the NES or SNES and Genesis. And now after 13 years, they have turned me away from the Wii cause majority of their game library consists of poorly made games. In my honest opinion, Nintendo's Wii is telling Developers that they don't need to try at all to make the games great cause they know people will buy it regardless.
  • 0
    Reason Oct 4, 08
    Thing is Nintendo aren't exactly 'digging their own grave'. They're just making more and more money and I know it'll continue because the casual gamer audience is so large and people love the big brands like Zelda and Mario.

    I do agree with the article though, Nintendo have completely tarnished their reputation with many hardcore gamers. I have a Wii and tbh I never really play it anymore, only thing that I want to get for it is Brawl now.
    • 1
      Big A2 Oct 4, 08
      quote
      only thing that I want to get for it is Brawl now
      If you don't have Brawl by now, then it's kinda obvious you don't have many of the other great Wii games.
  • 0
    Dark Arcanine Oct 4, 08
    Sadly there are so many fans who will buy it regardless and then there's that market sector of casual gamers they're appealing to which the other consoles neglect.
  • 0
    Capn Droid Oct 4, 08
    Perhaps they're digging a grave for their gaming era... but they certainly aren't dying out completely. Nintendo is certainly going to appeal to the public, gamer or not, with all these "new and innovative" "games". Perhaps we should have Miyamoto step down, despite the progress he's given to the company? He's the one creating all this WiiShit.
  • 1
    King X2 Oct 6, 08
    You need friends to have a fun time on the Wii. I agree with the article.
  • 1
    Daigoji_Gai Oct 7, 08
    Fatal Error nintendo isn't alienating anyone.... they've always been "family" and mass market friendly... Case in point: Nintendo's censorship of titles on the NES and SNES including Mortal Kombat because they were afraid of ruining the company image. No one is full of shit Fatal, you just seem not to acknowledge or realize the facts.
    • 2
      Fatal Error Oct 7, 08
      I seem to see a whole lot of "hardcore" gamers being completely alienated by the Wii. Got anything else for me, genius?
      • 0
        Big A2 Oct 7, 08
        You weren't a hardcore gamer before that NES was placed in front of you. What Nintendo is trying to do is invite more people into the world of gaming, there still are plenty of "hardcore" titles like Zelda and plenty more to come like Punch Out. Their only problem is the amount of shovelware that they let through.
        • 2
          Fatal Error Oct 8, 08
          Actually I was a hardcore gamer when the SNES was placed in front of me because I didn't care for games during the time of the NES. Thanks for essentially making my point for me though, which is that the Wii is alienating the hardcore gamers. Punch Out wasn't a hardcore game and a remake/new version of it wouldn't be either.

          Wii = new from Nintendo = direction Nintendo is heading = alienation of hardcore gamers. Good going, guys.
  • 0
    Daigoji_Gai Oct 8, 08
    Hmm, thanks for calling me a genius Fatal Error - you realized what helped me get to where I am!

    I would say Punch Out was hardcore for the time when it was originally released, and hardcore gamers nostalgic for the title will be picking it up... Big A2 was right, and there are titles (moreso legacy franchises) that will remain and continue to cater that hardcore audience. There is a shift in being more inclusive, but complete alienation cries from Fatal Error are melodramatic and overblown. Nintendo has always been about key franchises and a few "break through" new titles (like GoldenEye for the 64). Nothing has changed only that Nintendo is paying more attention to the wider gaming audience. The Zeldas, possible Kid Icarus, the Fire Emblems, etc will all be returning or have returned for the Wii.

    So other than blowing out upcoming hardcore games like MADWORLD and THE CONDUIT at E3, Nintendo hasn't really changed or is alienating anyone. The fact Monster Hunter 3 is heading to the Wii (which isn't for the faint of heart) along with the two titles I mentioned above (MADWORLD and THE CONDUIT) is no different for the Wii than it was for the N64 when we saw GoldenEye drop along with the usual return of Mario and Zelda...

    Just this year, at E3, Nintendo didn't make a big fuss about POINTING OUT OBVIOUSLY, that there are hardcore games in the works or on the way for the console, their intention for E3 (which is where these cries for alienation come) was Nintendo using the space to remind the world they have always been about family gaming and trying new (sometimes quirky) things, and bringing a new audience into the fold.

    That isn't alienation, that is business savvy.

This news story is archived and is closed to comments now.