Denis from Vorpal Bunny Ranch has put together a blog that talks about the "dandy" in video games - The overly feminine male character who is known for his pretty face, fashionable clothes, witty remarks, and unwillingness to get his hands dirty during a fight. Any fan of Japanese RPGs will be very familiar with the concept ...

It is curious how this occurs, though. Balthier in Final Fantasy XII is a pirate who is self-serving, and will work with the group for his fair share of the treasure. Setzer in Final Fantasy VI is a dashing airship pilot who kidnaps daring opera divas and will help the party if they happen to win in a gamble. Dante from the Devil May Cry series is an anti-hero with a devilish side. The feminization these men face sets to give them a bit of danger and makes them all slightly less than good—the rebel.

Therefore, the male whose foil the dandy plays is the stoic, quiet, restrained, and/or muscular type. So, with the two polar opposites being the effete dandy and tough, muscular guy, the metrosexual makes perfect sense as someone who toes this line, which is where I would argue a character like Dante actually fits. He resembles more a James Dean or Han Solo than an Oscar Wilde or Jareth, the Goblin King. It is even more curious to note how these dandies do fight, as they are bound to be included in some brawl.

They sing, use tools, prefer using guns, and cast spells (the notable exception to this is the venerable old sage, who has earned his right to cast). Occasionally they may engage with a sword, but these are the fencers, not the brawlers (see: Raphael Sorel of Soul Caliber). Finesse, not strength defines their character—which lends itself to us distrusting them. Would you trust a man who would not engage you in direct combat? In a "man's world," this is seen as an affront to honor. Those silly effete duelers, chatty and unwilling to muscle through a problem. You certainly wouldn't want to wrestle with them!
| More
Additional sources:
Register as a member to subscribe comments.
  • 0
    Dark Arcanine Nov 3, 08
    It's because they want to be like me. Ah well, I reckon it's to get girls more interested.
  • 2
    RabidChinaGirl Nov 3, 08
    I know this is just a random blog entry and not a serious academic discussion, but the blogger used very limited examples -- all of which are Japanese games. She mentions this trend is in JRPGs, but the GG headline doesn't. A little misleading.

    Honestly, Square Enix games need to be in a category of their own. There's feminine and then there's SquEnix-feminine....... as in you wonder if they even have a penis any more.

    Dante was made more masculine in DMC4 with the addition of facial hair, something used sparingly in Japanese games. It would have been more interesting to see a sound comparison of these men mentioned, because the blog post is really lacking. True, she notes that it's about Japanese games, but she doesn't discuss Japanese culture.

    A cursory analysis of Japanese culture and gender would shine quite a bit of light on the girly-guy syndrome. Our world, while following a general Western standard of development, is not uniform. People seem to forget that.
    • 0
      Exevier Nov 3, 08
      "There's feminine and then there's SquEnix-feminine....... as in you wonder if they even have a penis any more."

      lmao. Very well said, I must say.

      I have to agree, as well, about the article. It's a bit lacking and could have been a good deal more interesting. I've also got to argue the fact that Dante's mentioned. Sure, he's got the slick anime hair, but he's definitely not in the "afraid to get his hands dirty during a fight" category. Not to mention the facial hair in 4, and his character overall is much, much more masculine than most JRPG femi-men.
      • 0
        Cruxis Mana Nov 3, 08
        TBH, if you think Square Enix make them as feminine as they get, then you need to do some more research.

        (Y).
        • 2
          RabidChinaGirl Nov 3, 08
          No thanks! The possibility that there are male characters more feminine than Square Enix's recent creations frightens me...

          Actually, I know a few so there's no doubt they exist, but in my eyes Square Enix has a reputation built on it.
  • 1
    Final Blade Nov 3, 08
    Sorry me being a die hard DMC fan I completely disagree with Dante being in this list. I mean is it possible for a man to have some sort of fashion sense without being labeled as feminine? Anyway the rest was alright, but dante is far from being put on this list.
    • 0
      RabidChinaGirl Nov 3, 08
      There's also the obvious fact that DMC is a hyper-masculine series, which you can see based on how the hero behaves and his female cohorts... so I wouldn't consider Dante a suitable candidate for the blog either.

      That being said, I love Dante. Total babe -- in a manly-man kind of way, of course.
  • 0
    BANDITO ATTACK Nov 3, 08
    everyone in japan is like women it probably gets confusing.
  • 0
    HisServant77 Nov 3, 08
    Yeah . . . this is really only legit in the japanese type games. Where feminine men, is all the craze! Kidding . . . just kidding. At least I hope.
  • 0
    Play ISDF Nov 3, 08
    In my opinion, this is perfectly fine. Playing to the big muscled, gun wielding, kick ass hero, who always has a smoke definitely works sometimes but it's always nice to have some variation from that hero stereotype. That said, JRPG's do it far too much! Practically every single one has you using someone like in the article (since all it did was go after JRPG's, and not as well as it could have). Again that's perfectly fine, but Squeenix for instance (the greatest abuser of it) does it far too much. That doesn't meant they gotta go to the opposite extreme but seriously, all the Final Fantasy heroes are pretty much all related from at least their hair.

This news story is archived and is closed to comments now.