New Challenger: 3 Reasons Why Gaming Will Destroy Itself Part 1
19 hours 54 mins ago
Mike Fahey of Kotaku has written an interesting blog on the recent controveries surrounding homosexuality in the gaming world. Go to the source for the full article
BioWare's censoring of homosexual terms on the Star Wars: The Old Republic forums was not a wise move, but they certainly weren't the first video game company to struggle with the issue of homosexuality.
And they almost certainly won't be the last. Homosexuality has long been a controversial issue amongst gamers, developers, and publishers alike. With the ever-growing popularity of online games, players often bring their intolerance online, sharing it with their friends, teammates, and guilds. This tends to lead to knee-jerk reactions from the industry, with an unfortunate emphasis on the word jerk.




Comments
My suggestion is just to forget hiding it away and bring it straight out into the light. If people have a problem with it, then don't play the game. If they become abusive online, ban the buggers. There's no reason why everyone can't just get along, don't care about sexual preferences, and just play the game for FUN.
But you know though man, it's not fair to say, that people HAVE to respect anything, or anyone, that they disagree with or dont like. If anyone can DO anything, then anyone else can disagree. Now, the thing is there, that's fine, so long as; the person doing it (whether it's sexuality, religion, or anything man) doesnt force what they're doing into peoples faces, AND, so long as the person who disagrees or does something that's in conflict with it, doesnt FORCE the conflict. If either person does that, then they're in the wrong. They're looking for conflict. SO what i mean by this, is this. If people are being abusive, or aggressive to another person, because of their sexuality, then I ask this - if we're all only playing, JUST to play, and have fun, then why are you putting your sexuality out there? Why are you making people aware?
In this context, it's not the point of homosexuality. It's the point of, people WANTING to play games, and just play games. And other people are adding some sort of agenda, other than just playing games, out of insecurity, or just sheer disrespect to the other gamers. And that will upset people - you could be gay, straight, christian, muslim, buddhist, you could be a bloody martian; but as soon as you start forcing this into the game, there will be SOMEONE who disagrees, and airs that disagreement, rightly so. So maybe people are wrong to be abusive. But I'll tell you something - you're there to play a game. So the people that are giving others something to abuse them about, are wrong also. If they wanna discuss that, it can be done elsewhere. The purpose of games is gaming. So, ban the people who are abusive and aggresive; and ALSO, ban the people that are passively aggressively causing the conflicts, by saying "BLAH BLAH BLAH IM THIS WAY or THAT WAY AND YOU HAVE TO LIKE IT BLAH BLA BLAH" no, no-one does. They have to be civil, because OTHER people are playing the game too. And that's something that goes for everyone; no-one is above that.
I can understand why some people put their sexuality into games though. It's like saying you're part of a group or from a certain country or something and being proud of it. For instance I'm proud to say I'm an Aussie. And when people are connected to a certain thing, other people are connected to it as well. And when those people talk, they can create friendships and such easier since having common ground helps. It also tells you about yourself so people who aren't going to get along with you can avoid you and people who are going to like you and can be friends with you probably. Back in the early days of gaming you would just play games, but now with profiles attached to multiple games (like Xbox Live or Steam or whatever) that contain info about the player for people to read and contain stats about games played and whatever else, it's hardly surprising that people are going to include sexuality for instance. It's like having a mini-Facebook/Myspace/Whatever profile attached to your games. People are going to fill it up. And because of that, they should be able to put their sexuality in and not get targeted by the community. Sure there's always going to be a few twits who do it but still.
If we were still in the old days of gaming like with Diablo 2 I could agree with you, but with everything connected via services that contain info for people to read, I can't so much. Besides, if they don't learn tolerance somewhere, then when will they? At this rate, humanity as a whole are becoming more and more intolerant. No wonder the world is in a downwards spiral of sorts since we can't get along with those of different beliefs.
I don't like that lifestyles or practices that make some people uncomfortable has to be coerced into every aspect of our cultural society.
It's not a matter of tolerance but acceptance. If some gamers want to play a game with cool features but don't want to play a homosexual character because it makes them uncomfortable who is anyone to say that they should be tolerant of it?
That's where the disagreements come from...people, as carouselambra pointed out, being passively aggressive in forcing these issues on others as if it's something everyone should be okay with.
The fact that this maintains to be a global issue should be apparent enough that this is not "a okay" with everyone. And I agree that some issues -- unless the game is specifically dealing with that issue -- should be left out of the general gaming arena.
Keep it general and keep it fun.
There's a difference between, sharing the things that make you who you are, and on the other hand creating an issue; or a scene. If you share that information; EXPECT opposition. Dont expect everyone to accept or even aknowledge it. If an issue arises, you can ignore it. Or you can defend it. But if you do, expect a ban. Why? because if that information is not more important to you than playing the game, then dont share it. If it IS more important to you, then you have to respect, that once you start using the game as a means to attack, or pre-emptively defend who you are or what you are or what you do, then you no longer have a right to play this game. Because it's not your game. And if you keep doing it, you'll destroy what the game is, you'll ruin everyone's enjoyment. I'm all for unity and understanding; but that doesnt mean everyone will agree, all the time. And they shouldnt. Tolerate is fair enough, I can agree with that. But that works both ways - you can only tolerate, so long as they're not looking for trouble.
Yeh man vortis, there's a thin line between who's in the right and who's in the wrong. If you know something is gonna make someone uncomfortable, you've gotta ask - is it really THAT important that you share it? And that links in to what I said about looking for trouble. Some people do it just for a shock reaction, which is as bad, or worse even, as the people who HAVE an aggressive shock reaction. It's about responsibility. The fact is, as soon as you put any bit of information about yourself out there, you have a duty to defend it. If you dont want to, dont share it. If you know it's gonna get attacked, and you're not prepared to deal with that, then dont share it. Because, where do you draw the line? If people start sharing very disturbing explicit things, or very racist views, or something illegal even; can you still say, they have a right to share that? How many people does it have to offend before it's deemed "offensive"? I think, anything put there with the express intent of offending anyone, is what you can say is offensive. That goes for, the people that outright insult, and the people that do it the passive way, by looking to attract insult. Everyone else, just do what you do, be happy. If you're happy with what you do, who you are, (this goes for anything not just sexuality), then it doesnt matter what they say or think. I dont like it, I'll be honest, I don't agree with it as a life choice. And I understand why some of the younger crowd, perhaps, say the things they do. But that doesnt matter. That's my opinion. That's their opinion. what's YOUR opinion? They dont live for you, you do. Do what you want, no-one really cares so long as it's not in front of them. So as long as people keep to themselves, things will keep working. You dont need people's aknowledgment, respect the lines, and everyone else will. Or should, anyway. And if they dont, then fair enough, they'll be banned. Because otherwise, the game as a whole stops functioning, and stops being enjoyable. This isnt face-to-face contact or conflict or social meets - this is recreation, hobby - GAME. If you go to a snooker hall and start creating an issue, you'll get chucked out. If you go to a swimming pool, and do anything other than swim, you're liable to be chucked out. If you start arguing about sexuality in a football match, you'll be sent off. Because that's not what it's there for. That's not what YOU'RE there for. It's not matching up, I'm afraid. And it's not matching up, in these games. If they're that angry go on a march or something man. then come back and play the game. As a game.
By the way, so there's no misunderstanding, when I say "YOU", no-one has to worry I'm not directing that to anyone in particular
This news story is archived and is closed to comments now.