It's no secret that Japan takes its cosplay seriously. They have cosplay courses at certain universities, cosplay 'friend' services, cosplayers greeting tourists at airports, and cosplay street parties. A quick look at those links will show you that the Japanese spend alot of time and money trying to look EXACTLY like their favorite game or anime characters.

But what about Westerners? Well, there's a stereotype that Westerners simply can't cosplay... or can't cosplay as well as the Japanese, anyway. But is that true? Is Japanese cosplay really better than Western cosplay? Kotaku takes a look...

There is a stereotype - an unfair stereotype - that Westerners cannot cosplay.

"A Japanese friend of mine told me very casually, in a totally matter-of-fact kind of way, that the difference between Japanese and American cosplay is as clear as moeru and naeru," says Patrick Galbraith, author of The Otaku Encycolpedia, University of Tokyo PhD candidate and cosplaying Akihabara tour guide. "Moeru" means "to bud", while "naeru"is an antonym and means "to wilt"."

The connection in the minds of Westerners between cosplay and Japanese popular culture is natural and makes sense. What does not make sense is the notion that cosplay is exclusively Japanese or that Japanese cosplayers are intrinsically better at cosplaying than their Western counterparts. It's not that one is better than the other, they're just different.
| More
Images about this story:
Register as a member to subscribe comments.
  • 1
    Curt Connors Dec 29, 09
    Uh, most tenuous game related article ever?
    • 0
      Euphoric Dec 30, 09
      There's been more than a few lately.
  • 1
    HisServant77 Dec 29, 09
    Maybe I'm biased, but it doesn't matter to me if Westerners are not as good at cosplay as the Japanese culture. In fact, I kinda lean toward saying that's a good thing.
  • 1
    Dragoshi1 Dec 29, 09
    The hundreds of Kingdom Hearts/Final Fantasy themed cosplayers that show up at conventions in america are staggering. No variety at all. Cloud here, Sora there,there AND there, oh look an Inuyasha!

    Thats why I never go anymore. No variety.

    Also 3 quarters of the cosplayers are not eye candy, quite the opposite actually.
  • 1
    carouselambra Dec 29, 09
    meh, they might be crap at it, but doesnt matter. That's their thing innit, if they enjoy it no worries man, who can tell em not to, doesnt hurt anyone, good luck to em the freakin weirdos
    • 1
      Hideo1 Dec 30, 09
      Yeah, they're really crap at what they do. Hey you cosplayer; you suck at cosplaying! But it's okay, peace and love, if they like it then good for them, even though they suck at it and are freaking weirdos. Yeah, you, you cosplaying weirdo, you suck at what you do and are a freak but I love you, peace and love you *bleep*ing freak.
      • 1
        carouselambra Dec 30, 09
        pretty much man have we got an echo in the room?
        • 0
          Hideo1 Dec 30, 09
          Nah, I just wanted to make sure they really understood how crappy they should feel, since they're not too bright.
        • 0
          carouselambra Dec 31, 09
          I see. Well they shouldnt feel too bad, not everyone can be blessed with super-human intelligence and well-endowedness like carouselambra. Not to lose perspective though, the point is anyway they do it for themself, they dont do it for me or anyone else. I've yet to be ambushed by a gang of cosplayers, so if that's how they wanna spend their time leave em to it man; they're not producing a film or something, it's dress-up innit, doesnt matter how good or bad they are at it.
        • 0
          HisServant77 Dec 31, 09
          Carousel . . . you just gave me a hilarious image of a group of cosplayers mobbing you and you screaming out, with them pulling you to the ground saying, "Join us . . . JOIN us!!!"

          Thank you
  • 1
    BANDITO ATTACK Dec 29, 09
    black mario bros+wario is the best cosplay ever
  • 1
    Ammy and Issun Dec 30, 09
    I don't think Western cosplay is really bad at all.

    It's pretty ok, but of course Japanese ones are better.

This news story is archived and is closed to comments now.