161

Nintendo loses $21 million on patent infringement case

Nintendo have always prided themselves on their originality. Unfortunately in this case the courts do not agree.
Back in 2006 a small Texas based gaming company called Anascape sued Nintendo for patent infringement in the creation of the Wii, Wavebird and Gamecube controllers. After almost two years the courts have ruled in favour of Anascape, and Nintendo must now pay $21 million compensation to Anascape and while Nintendo can certainly spare the cash this is definitely a humiliating blow.
On Wednesday a federal jury ruled in favor of Anascape, a small East Texas-based gaming company, in a lawsuit that was originally filed in 2006, the Associated Press reports. The jury found that Nintendo infringed on Anascape's patent while designing its Wii Classic, WaveBird and Gamecube controllers.



Nintendo will seek an appeal in a bid to have the $21 million award "significantly" reduced, according to a spokesperson, who said that the company was pleased that no infringement was found with the motion-sensing technology used in its Wii Remote and Nuncheck controllers.
18 comments | go to source (www.next-gen.biz) | Add to favorites! favourite this article | send to friend | add alt source
Register as a member to subscribe comments.

Comments with -10 or lower "thumbs" are removed from display.

  • 0 thumbs!
    chautemoc | May 15, 2008
    Ouch . =/
  • 0 thumbs!
    Akira_EX | May 15, 2008
    It would be a humiliating blow if Anascape was a company that actually did anything. But in the case of actually having no real product, and almost next-to-none information about the company, you can say that it's a bullshit move.

    This isn't the first time the US patent system has shown its problems, and won't be the last.
  • 0 thumbs!
    twilightprince | May 15, 2008
    Yeah, this isn't humiliating at all.

    Anascape, as a company, is humiliating.
  • -2 thumbs!
    vaga_koleso | May 15, 2008
    Umm, he said "Analscape". Hehe.
  • 0 thumbs!
    Jeterocks | May 15, 2008
    Come on now. With that Logic you are saying that Anascape is a joke company because they may not have the funds that Nintendo have. They obviously had the ideas to create something great, but not the funds to go through with their idea.

    This is what big companies thrive on. Finding the small company that can't do squat with their idea, mooching off their idea and actually putting a product into production that the small company couldn't do.
    • 0 thumbs!
      Akira_EX | May 15, 2008
      At the same time, there are companies that file for patents and just sit on them, waiting for others to infringe on them and make bank on the lawsuit.
    • 0 thumbs!
      Magimaster | May 15, 2008
      Well there's no point in sitting on a patent and not doing anything with it and not letting other companies who have the resources actually do something with the idea. Granted, they did come up with the idea and the credit should go to them but what's the point of depriving the world of their idea just because they're selfish enough to not let anyone with the resources touch it? Guess capitalism just makes you selfish.

      Anyways, I find it funny that anyone who said something against Anascape got a thumbs down.
  • -1 thumbs!
    chautemoc | May 15, 2008
    These comments make me wonder how far people would go to defend Nintendo, even if they were proven guilty of something..
    Not saying they are or aren't either way..
    • 0 thumbs!
      twilightprince | May 17, 2008
      Even if it was Sony or Microsoft, or any other company for that matter, I would still react the same.

      I hate when companies file patents ... then do nothing with them. They just wait for big companies to create something remotely similar to their patent, then they sue for millions. It's disgusting. If you're gonna file a patent, ACTUALLY CREATE THE PRODUCT.
  • -1 thumbs!
    DusktoDawn | May 15, 2008
    The company just had to pay 21 million, so what?
    • 2 thumbs!
      Raziel_326 | May 15, 2008
      You make is sound like $21 million isn't much. I know some nintendo fanboys will respond and say some shit like "$21 mill is pocket change for Nintendo". It doesn't matter how much money you have, $21 million is still quite a damn lot of money to lose over something like this.
    • 0 thumbs!
      Final Blade | May 16, 2008
      By your logic its like saying "MS losing 1.9 billion is nothing", which it is something. I know MS has alot of money but 1.9 billion is incredible amount of money to lose.

      Anyway this sucks for Nintendo.
      But it sucks more for Anascape.
  • 1 thumbs!
    BANDITO ATTACK | May 15, 2008
    its all about the <3 of the $$$
  • 0 thumbs!
    RikuNova | May 16, 2008
    Ouch...that is a huge loss for Nintendo...
    • 0 thumbs!
      Starborn | May 18, 2008
      Not a relly huge loss, maybe in sales and stuff, but nintendo mas millions. They're going to lose money from the embarassment though.
  • 0 thumbs!
    tornjinx | May 16, 2008
    Twi's got it in full. Nintendo shouldn't be humiliated. Anascape being a company still in business, that is the humiliating part.
  • 0 thumbs!
    Starborn | May 18, 2008
    That's not good for Nintendo. Their products are going to be less popular, and they lose a little bit of money. I would still buy Nintendo stuff though, it's not a huge concern to me =p.
  • -1 thumbs!
    Master Jynch | May 20, 2008
    That's a bit of a fail. One would think that Nintendo should be free from it just because some tiny company patented something and did nothing with it. The American justice system fails that way.

This news story is archived and is closed to comments now.

Submit Newshelp

Top Contributors

This Month
Gothic Girl 2433 pts
chautemoc 1355 pts
Deathsythe 1091 pts
Tyranitar24 1069 pts
Akira_EX 849 pts
Silver Mir.. 841 pts
Cruxis Mana 297 pts
Krunal 259 pts
Final Blade 252 pts
tallteen86 239 pts
All-Time
Gothic Girl 16692 pts
Krunal 12070 pts
Linkin Par.. 9940 pts
Final Blade 8858 pts
xsynergyx 8079 pts
Silver Mir.. 8027 pts
mistermostyn 7868 pts
chautemoc 7807 pts
ITANI 6350 pts
Akira_EX 6029 pts

Stats

Today
Published News: 6
Comments: 20
Points Given: 94
Users Registered: 0
This Month
Published News: 535
Comments: 4990
Points Given: 9485
Users Registered: 34
All Time
Published News: 10214
Comments: 69364
Points Given: 164334
Users Registered: 509

Conventions / Trade Shows

(0.1347/d/aeon)