The metacritic fanboy war continues. Some time ago, Resistance 2 scores were lowered by 360 fanboys. And then the same has happened to KillZone 2. To get revenge on these 360 fanboys, a large number of PS3 fanboys have got together to lower the score of Halo Wars. They have succeeded, and the score of Halo Wars now resides at 0.8 out of 10.

Now this really does disapoint me for many reasons, the worst of which is that there are actually people out there who would create an account on Metacritic.com with the purpose just to post a low score for a game which isn’t even out yet on a console they may not even own and just because its on the “rival Console” and won’t even take into account if it is a good game or not. The fact that this also happened to other major releases last year such as Resistance 2, Gears of War 2 and LittleBigPlanet, now means that we can no longer take an user scores into account when deciding whenever to buy a game or not, since they will always have the chance of being corrupted by this petty “fanboy war”. Hopefully this will only be a Short-term problem and that people will soon stop this since they notice what they are doing is just sad at the end of the day.
| More
News story attached to:
Images about this story:
Latest comment:
Most recently commented on by on Jan 7, 2009
Register as a member to subscribe comments.
  • 1
    HawkMan Jan 4, 09
    ahahahaha awesome! bastards sarted this the sony fanboys are going to end it.

    the article makes a good point tho. still funny.
    • 1
      Gamesta100 Jan 4, 09
      End it my arse.Next game this will happen to will be Killzone 2.It's be like gang murders, one murders a gang member and then another gang member is murdered in retaliation all becoming an endless cycle.
    • 7
      FinalFantasyFanaticc Jan 4, 09
      Wow, you just back up the assumption that all fanboys are pathetic idiots, good job.
      • 0
        Gamesta100 Jan 4, 09
        Well when I say fanboy, I only mean the pathetic idiots.I don't say fanboy if I'm talking about people like me who completely prefer one company ie. Sony over the others.Personally I ONLY think of people like these as fanboys.That is people that are so damn loyal to a given company that it's like they are their God.

        So I'm not making any assumptions, it's YOU who are making the assumptions.
        • 0
          Capn Droid Jan 4, 09
          I believe he was referring to HawkMan.
        • 2
          FinalFantasyFanaticc Jan 4, 09
          Yeah, sorry if your confused Gamesta, but as Capn Droid stated, i was referring to HawkMan.
      • 0
        HawkMan Jan 5, 09
        speaking of pathetic idiots, whats up FFFanatic?
        • 1
          pooOBKp Jan 5, 09
          Seriously HawkMan, that was such a good insult! *High five* faggot
  • 14
    Darknet Jan 4, 09
    So childish and immature.
  • 6
    Gamesta100 Jan 4, 09
    Pathetic losers with no life.No wonder some people think so lowly of gamers.
  • 0
    joshthegreat Jan 4, 09
    That's why you never read the user-score on Metacritic. Metacritic is a great site for looking at a vairety of reviews for a product, they just should have never given it a member-base.
  • 0
    Stefan Jan 4, 09
    i dont use the site at all. but surely the metacritic score is taken with a pinch of salt these days?
    • 3
      Hunskelper Jan 4, 09
      Not really. Metacritic's an excellent site for getting a general view of a game.

      However, user reviews on any site can easily be manipulated by a group with an agenda.
  • 1
    Newcloud Jan 4, 09
    the real review will probably be 0.9 XD there not far of LOL
  • 0
    EOM Bassist Jan 4, 09
    There's some petty and pathetic people out there isn't there? I mean, they're effectively getting the 360 fanboys back with their own low tactics they used against the PS3 fanboys. Don't you just wish these fools would stop caring?
  • 0
    Onvacation Jan 4, 09
    Why do metacritic even allow User reviews before the game is even out, Seems pretty stupid to me.
  • 1
    Red 9 Jan 4, 09
    So the juvenile game of cat and mouse begins again...nice job, you fools, it's no wonder the only place you geeks actually see girls is on Home...
  • 1
    Existence Jan 4, 09
    *bleep*ing losers. I'm a PS3 guy, but I would never stoop as low as giving 360 games low ratings. What the hell are they gonna get from this? Metacritic should employ some review moderators to avoid these incidents.
  • 1
    PangTong_Blademaster Jan 4, 09
    Hahaha. Call them sad all you like, but it's still funny watching people getting wound up over other people's opinions.
    • 1
      Red 9 Jan 4, 09
      Opinions, opinions, opinions. These are not opinions on metacritic we're seeing; it's blind hatred and immaturity. It's painting a bad picture for the rest of us. We can laugh, sure, but doesn't make it any less ridiculous.
  • 2
    Slumpy monkey Jan 4, 09
    This game isn't even out yet. Lmao.
  • 0
    Cruxis Mana Jan 4, 09
    It must have been fairly low already though, for it to drop as far as it has done.
    • 0
      Slumpy monkey Jan 4, 09
      I think it was at 5. Seeing as its not out, Obviously it wasn't going to have any reviews for it yet/

      So this wave of 0's is why is dropped so low.
      • 0
        Red 9 Jan 4, 09
        Regardless of whether it's out or not, you wouldn't be able to take the user rating seriously. 1) we all know it's just PS3 fanboys being spiteful, and 2) I doubt any game would have that low a user rating without fanboys.
        • 0
          Slumpy monkey Jan 4, 09
          what? I was just responding to cruxis saying the score must have been low to start with.
        • 0
          Red 9 Jan 4, 09
          I was just saying, it doesn't matter whether or not the game is out yet, it's obvious that the user reviews are bogus, hence the article seen above.

          It was just a wordy way of agreeing with you.
  • 0
    Duality_18 Jan 4, 09
    I think its funny. Hell, this type of thing is weird to see. How organized some people can become. Half the time i'll be at my friends house with a group of friends and we cant get the ball rolling on anything.

    But a complete group of strangers can ban together and lower a review score below 1.0

    Maybe their is some light hidden away in all this darkness of fanboyism?
    • 0
      HisServant77 Jan 4, 09
      Yeah that is a bit funny to think how strangers can band together like that . . . indeed haha
  • 0
    Krunal Jan 4, 09
    For god sakes, stop with these score wars. NO ONE CARES ABOUT USER REVIEW SCORES BECAUSE OF WHAT YOU ARE ALL DOING.
  • 0
    Insanity Prevails* Jan 4, 09
    Shouldn't these people be spending less time trying to make rival console games appear worse and more time actually playing the games on the console they own? I can't help but think that with acts like this these people are missing the point of owning a games console and are taking the whole situation too seriously.

    If someone throws a pissy fit and decides to do something like this to 'get one up' over the rivals then they really should be rethinking their priorities.
  • 1
    Taker4ever Jan 4, 09
    Who pays attention to user-scores anyway? The only user reviews I ever take heed of are well-written and self-consciously approached ones, or by users whom I know to be reliable and unbiased.

    The real loser out of all this though is Metacritic. Gives them some bad publicity; they'd be better adding some sort of moderation policy for user reviews before this all gets even more out of hand.
  • 1
    Jesh Jan 4, 09
    I don't really mind this, Metacritic is the best site for how good a game is...but no one cares about user scores.
  • 0
    DragoniteBallZ Jan 4, 09
    Wow Killzone 2 and Halo Wars have such low scores. They sure showed each other.
  • 0
    Shinobi_razor Jan 4, 09
    fanboys are so silly!
  • 0
    xxxRockerxxx Jan 4, 09
    That's just sad to actually do that.
  • 3
    HisServant77 Jan 4, 09
    . . . . h . . .hh . . . HAHAHA! I'm so sorry but this is really funny!

    If you're a kid and among friends and everything, this type of retaliation is hilarious and good for some laughs at how low each party can get the other's score to be.

    Yet, in real life and considering business and the fact that these scores are the deciding factor for a lot of people, and how many take it WAY too seriously, this is truly pathetic, indeed a reason gamers have a bad rep, and a show of how ridiculous fanboyism can be!
  • 0
    Gamesta100 Jan 4, 09
    Ah.Sucks that GG doesn't always put replies in the right spot.
  • 11
    Seeker X Jan 4, 09
    "We severely bombarded Halo Wars, sir."
    "Hah, that should make up for losing Killzone 2."
    "Yes, sir, which should we get next?"
    "Oh wait, hold up, my mom's making me get off the comp, g2g."
    • 1
      HisServant77 Jan 4, 09
      Haha, It wouldn't surprise me one bit if that indeed is the conversation with some of them
  • 0
    Killosity Jan 5, 09
    Shame stuff like this has to happen.
    But little retards will be, little retards.
    And im sure both titles will be all good.

    BUT KILLZONE 2 WILL BE BETTER! (runs off and user rates)
  • 0
    Final Blade Jan 5, 09
    You *bleep*ing Idiots. You're not one upping anyone. All you're doing is feeding the BS some more with the retaliation. And now watch as the 360 fanboys retaliate with Zero's to God of War 3, Heavy Rain and infamous(whatever it's called).

    People like you is the sole reason I hate console fanboys and give us intelligent console users a bad name.
  • 0
    Zero and X Jan 5, 09
    Fanboys are a waste of life.
  • 0
    The Omega Jan 5, 09
    Much like I've mentioned before that user scores don't mean much to me, only the review does, the same goes with user reviews. This is pointless and makes gamers look like children, when it's only crazy fanboys who take things way too seriously.
  • 1
    Bale Fire* Jan 5, 09
    I find this funny, I don't see why everyone is getting so wound up about it. It doesn't really effect you in anyway.
    • 0
      Final Blade Jan 5, 09
      Some people can't tolerate blatant fanboyish idiocy.
      • 1
        Bale Fire* Jan 5, 09
        I understand being a little annoyed or just plain perplexed. But some people here seem to be furious.
        • 0
          Capn Droid Jan 7, 09
          GRRRR WTF RAGE SOMEONE IS THUMBING DOWN MY FAVORITE HYPED UP GAME EVER ON MY FAVORITE HYPED UP CONSOLE EVER!!! I AM GOING TO SEETHE NOW >:[
  • 0
    Nightfire101 Jan 5, 09
    I'm confused about how low, and immature, both parties went.

    It's a game, and a console. Why should you care if your game is given low marks.

    The best thing the PS3 folk should have done was report or whatever they have on Metacritic, and turned the other cheek.

This news story is archived and is closed to comments now.