Comments with -5 or lower "thumbs" are removed from display.

• 
  0 thumbs!

  Wolfwood | September 07, 2007
  I haven't played Lair myself (or even own a PS3 at time of writing) so I can't comment on the game itself. For all the musing over the value of scoring games in reviews w/o a standard criteria, the folks at SDF were probably having some fun with it all by giving it a STUPENDOUS 10/10 review. Complete with lines like this:
  
  

  quote

  Make no mistake, Lair could very well be this generation’s “Mario 64″. With greater use of motion control than any Wii game and better graphics than any 360 game I think it’s safe to say we have a candidate for game of the year right here.

  It's fine if you really like the game IMO, but the review sounds so over the top!
  • 
    0 thumbs!

    Final Blade | September 07, 2007
    I think Its fine, i mean they have played the game and understand the game to its fullest they would know how awesome it is. And it could perhaps be the next Mario 64, im thinking of getting this game. No doubt its going to be awesome
• 
  0 thumbs!

  Revenger of Wastelan | September 07, 2007
  Why did they give Bioshock a 5/10? Because they are some sick fan boys.
  • 
    0 thumbs!

    MrSponget | September 07, 2007
    "Hey did you know that BioShock was confirmed for the PS3?"
    "OH SHIT. We gotta up that review of it from 5/10 to 10/10."
    
    (I know, there probably wont be a PS3 Bioshock)
• 
  0 thumbs!

  Incidnia | September 07, 2007
  BioShock gets a 9/10 so far from me and I'm early through the game, and I hear it get's a lot better. And if this is all true...
  
  
  GameInformer US - [10/10]
  EGM - [10/10]
  GamePro - [10/10]
  1UP - [10/10]
  UK EuroGamer - [10/10]
  OXM - [10/10]
  X360 Gamer - [10/10]
  X360 - [10/10]
  OXMA - [10/10]
  PC Powerplay - [10/10]
  Game Arena - [10/10]
  Meristation - [10/10]
  Gamer.tv - [10/10]
  GamesRadar - [10/10]
  GameWorld - [10/10]
  Console - [10/10]
  GameTap - [10/10]
  Console Game World - [10/10]
  Alemania 360 Live - [9.8/10]
  Hyper - [9.7/10]
  IGN - [9.7/10]
  PC Zone - [9.6/10]
  PC Gamer - [9.5/10]
  UnderGround Online - [9.5/10]
  TXB - [9.5/10]
  Xbox World - [9.4/10]
  
  
  then SDF has nothing.
• 
  3 thumbs!

  volacide | September 07, 2007
  That's *bleep*ed, a 10/10, I hate these guys.
• 
  0 thumbs!

  tallteen86 | September 07, 2007
  Site is biased too much...
  
  Well, I don't care about them, if I want reviews, I usually check IGN or something...
• 
  0 thumbs!

  Raziel_326 | September 08, 2007
  Even though I think LAIR has been getting rather unfair grades, it sure as *bleep* doesn't deserve anywhere near a 10/10.
• 
  1 thumbs!

  FRoGBuster | September 08, 2007
  hahahaha. Don't you guys know SDF is supposed to be a parody? They're not serious. 10/10 for Lair and 5/10 for Bioshock should be enough for you to laugh at. Not get all fussy about how biased they are. SDF is Joking.!
  • 
    0 thumbs!

    Final Blade | September 08, 2007
    Good point. But you do know there are several 360 games that get perfect reviews which don't deserve it. Like bioshock. I mean its a good game but still shouldn't be 10/10
• 
  0 thumbs!

  ConkerASkyJockey | September 08, 2007
  If a game is 10/10, it means its perfect. Everyone can enjoy and has no flaws. Which is historicaly impossible.
  
  I say, LAIR doesn't deserve a rating near 10, maybe a 7.5 should be it.
  
  Bioshock should get a 8/10 IMO.
• 
  0 thumbs!

  Silver Mirror | September 08, 2007
  I agree that Bioshock doesn't deserve 10/10. It like Grand Theft Auto. Its hyped for months and when people actually touch it they instantly go into the frame of mind where there mind presumes everyone else likes it so they should as well as well as ignoring faults which you would normally notice
  
  And while Lair doesn't deserve 10/10 from my experience of it it easily deserves a 7/10 or 8/10
• 
  0 thumbs!

  Final Blade | September 08, 2007
  I guess you guys missed what FRoGBuster just said, there joking, there just saying that the game is so awesome it owns but in a non serious way. My guess its a backlash at the lair biased critics and Bioshock biased critics. I can't believe some fell for it.