Comments with -5 or lower "thumbs" are removed from display.

• 
  -1 thumbs!

  Supernouva | December 08, 2007
  I still think COD4 should've won Game of the Year, even though it's only been out for a few weeks. But it won best shooter and best military game, so it's all good.
• 
  -4 thumbs!

  Final Blade | December 08, 2007
  No surprise I would have chosen Bioshock for best game of the year myself. And no surprises on Halo 3.
  I pretty much agree with the winners, especially Ratchet and Clank the best PS3 game of the year. Great job, looks like CoD4 had several awards. Best shooter and Military game i agree
• 
  -2 thumbs!

  Supernouva | December 08, 2007
  I thought Heavenly Sword would've won best PS3 game.
  • 
    -3 thumbs!

    Final Blade | December 08, 2007
    Maybe but since Heavenly Sword storyline was short that may had played an effect, i still believed it was a candidate though or like runner up.
• 
  -1 thumbs!

  Shadow2k5 | December 08, 2007
  The results seem pretty accurate. Just surprised Assassins Creed didn't make it. Still I'm glad RaC got on there
• 
  -1 thumbs!

  Storm | December 08, 2007
  I agree with most of the choices...meh, BioShock. I think Mass Effect should be Best 360 game, and CoD4 should be GOTY. Still, happy with the majority of the results.
• 
  0 thumbs!

  sm1ff3rs | December 08, 2007
  Im happy Galaxy made Best Action Game & Best Wii Game
• 
  0 thumbs!

  Rinkydink | December 08, 2007
  Didn't think that the list was decent at all to be honest, as all of the Game of the Year nominees were exactly the same as the nominees for the best 360 games. The fact that Super Mario Galaxy wasn't even a Game of the Year nominee is laughable.
  
  At least the rest of the list seems decent enough.
• 
  2 thumbs!

  TurMoiL911 | December 08, 2007

  quote

  GAME OF THE YEAR
  BioShock
  
  BEST SHOOTER
  Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare (Activision/ Infinity Ward)
  
  BEST MILITARY GAME
  Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare (Activision/ Infinity Ward)
  

  Sounds about right to me.
  
  

  quote

  MOST ADDICTIVE VIDEO GAME FUELED BY DEW
  Halo 3 (Microsoft Game Studios/ Bungie Studios)

  Now that's just *bleep*ing rigged. I bet some Halo extremists petitioned for that category because their dear Halo 3 didn't win anything else.
• 
  0 thumbs!

  Linkin Park Fan | December 08, 2007
  What other game besides halo was fueled by mountain dew?
  • 
    3 thumbs!

    TurMoiL911 | December 08, 2007
    Exactly, it's kind of *bleep*ing given. Why make an entirely new category with no other nominations ?
  • 
    -1 thumbs!

    Incidnia | December 08, 2007
    That was the joke. How don't you get that?
• 
  -1 thumbs!

  slumpy monkey | December 08, 2007
  well it won bets multi player game^^^
• 
  -1 thumbs!

  tallteen86 | December 08, 2007
  Yeah, the Halo Dew one was rigged for sure >_>
  
  Kinda surprised (what with all the Halo fanboys) that Halo 3 didn't win Best 360 game >_>
  
  Assassin's Creed didn't win anything, probably because of all the glitching, it irritated everyone....not to mention, it wasn't THAT great of a game, from what I've currently played >_>
• 
  0 thumbs!

  Final Blade | December 08, 2007
  Of course there going to give Halo 3 the best multi-player game of the year thats what halo is known for after all, though i wished Warhawk won something
• 
  0 thumbs!

  StabWound | December 08, 2007
  Everything I expected except DiRT getting best racing...
• 
  1 thumbs!

  Red 9 | December 09, 2007
  I agree with everything except the GOTY winner and best online. Best online should've been Warhawk. As for what GOTY should've been...well, maybe Bioshock is a good choice, I guess it just doesn't fit my tastes. Though I'm sad the PS3's only award was in Best PS3 Game and nowhere else.
• 
  0 thumbs!

  Auctoria | December 09, 2007
  I'm surprised about Assassin's Creed.
  
  LOL@PS3
• 
  1 thumbs!

  Silver Mirror | December 09, 2007
  Best multiplayer should have been Warhawk. I mean it has bigger maps, no lag, more players and a dedicated team which continually updates and fixes the game
• 
  -3 thumbs!

  LordMaChao | December 09, 2007
  I honestly don't understand how you guys could think Warhawk is a better multiplayer game than Halo 3, CoD4 and Team Fortress 2.
  
  Glad BioShock got GOTY.
  • 
    0 thumbs!

    Seeker X | December 09, 2007
    It's not much of an enigma, but that's ok, since you haven't played it.
    • 
      -1 thumbs!

      LordMaChao | December 09, 2007
      Haha, yeah, you’re right. Compared to these guys, who probably have played Halo 3 and Team Fortress for hours and hours, I’ve got no right to judge. What was I thinking.
      • 
        0 thumbs!

        Seeker X | December 09, 2007
        Oh forgot...popular opinion = truth
        
        Never said Warhawk was the "obviously better game and it should've been chosen" (while it did look like it) I'm just saying is that Warhawk is a damn good piece of work and should not be discredited as such.
• 
  0 thumbs!

  Red 9 | December 09, 2007
  I think the reason Warhawk didn't get anything was because it has no tutorial, so if you're inexperienced, there's nowhere to train. Plus, it's got a whole different style that people aren't used to.
  
  Besides, Spike is just a bunch of duded with too much testosterone. Of course they'll like Halo over anything else.
• 
  0 thumbs!

  Final Blade | December 09, 2007
  Samuel L Jackson was hosting the show and he is a xbox fan or shooter fans i forgot from last year. by all the thumbs down on every comment. Even mine where i agree with the xbox and game winners what gives people. I just don't get it people.
• 
  0 thumbs!

  LordMaChao | December 09, 2007
  Oh, here I forgot popular opinion = wrong.
  
  Gawsh, this exchange is so full of wit.
  
  I never said I hated Warhawk. I haven't played it. But CoD4 is getting near perfect reviews from EVERYONE. Hundreds of thousands are playing Halo 3 online. Yet somehow those facts work AGAINST those games in your logic.
  
  finalblade98, you get negative thumbs because you produce nothing but incoherent dribble. The rest of these guys are just posting legitimate opinions that someone else disagrees with, so they give it a thumbs down. Who cares.
  • 
    -2 thumbs!

    Final Blade | December 09, 2007
    That shouldn't account for thumbs down. Two things should be considered before thumbing people down, one if you disagree and two if im flaming or arguing which i done non of in this article. Your all abusing the thumb ratings.
  • 
    1 thumbs!

    Seeker X | December 09, 2007
    HOLY SHIT, game reviewers say Call of Duty 4 is *bleep*ing perfect! I should just discard every game I got just for that. You know what a 10/10 is? A flawless game, and I'm pretty sure you're smart enough to know that not everyone loves CoD4, right?
    
    Now if you actually paid attention to my comment, you'd know that I'm not saying that Warhawk is officially better than CoD4, but your little reasoning resides with "If popular reviewers say it's true, then my opinion is worth shit now" way of thinking, kinda like Sheep Herding, if you will.
    • 
      -1 thumbs!

      LordMaChao | December 09, 2007
      God you're annoying.
      
      I'll just shrug off how you implied I misinterpreted you and then proceeded to completely misinterpret me.
• 
  3 thumbs!

  Deadman Rules | December 09, 2007
  The last one on the list makes me laugh. Seriously they just need an excuse to give that shitty game another award, which doesn't deserve multiplayer either because it's so flawed. Mass Effect was GOTY despite what the VGA's say. Bioshock was fun for a little bit then there was no replay value whatsoever and it wasn't as orgasmtastic as everyone made it out to be. Dirt isn't racer of the year either, we all know Forza 2 is. The rest of the list is right though besides those few things.
  
  At least COD4 got shooter of the year like it deserved.
  
  One more thing, how can a game win breakthrough techonogly? Haven't video games been around for quite some time? I thought it was suppose to be a hardware award? Meh.
  • 
    -1 thumbs!

    Final Blade | December 09, 2007
    I guess it got break through technology cause its vastly different from others game we have seen. I agree with you on Halo and Bioshock about no replay value.
• 
  0 thumbs!

  BANDITO ATTACK | December 09, 2007
  i could have told you this exact list without even reading it
  • 
    0 thumbs!

    Deadman Rules | December 09, 2007
    Have you even played Dirt and Forza?
• 
  0 thumbs!

  Dark Dom | December 09, 2007
  MHF2 should've gotten Handheld, but I guess this isn't a Japanese rating.
  
  "MOST ADDICTIVE VIDEO GAME FUELED BY DEW"
  
  What the hell?
• 
  0 thumbs!

  kEaNo10 | December 09, 2007
  I am actually very suprised by this list, some unknown to me.
• 
  3 thumbs!

  Seproth | December 09, 2007
  How can game of the year not be the best game in it's own genre...
  
  Sucks that Mass Effect only got best RPG. I think Orange Box or Mass Effect deserved GoTY. Sure as hell glad Halo 3 didn't get it though.
  
  I do think Halo 3 has some amazing music though. I would've liked to have seen it win that.
  
  Lol, at best graphics. It's pretty much as bad as best game fueled by dew. Of course crysis was going to take home that.
• 
  0 thumbs!

  Danger | December 09, 2007
  I've played majority of the games on the list here. Definitely deserve to be there. Bioshock had me gripped for days, the storyline is just fantastic.
• 
  0 thumbs!

  HBK619 | December 09, 2007
  BEST DRIVING GAME
  DiRT (Codemasters/ Codemasters)
  
  Didn't see that one coming.
  
  
  
  BEST MULTI-PLAYER GAME
  Halo 3 (Microsoft Game Studios/ Bungie Studios)
  
  Should have been COD4.
  
  
  
  Other than that, I have no qualms with the results.
• 
  0 thumbs!

  Jesh | December 09, 2007
  I am surprised Phantom's Hourglass got handheld game, I expected Pokemon to get it, TBH.
• 
  0 thumbs!

  strike_vanisher | December 09, 2007
  So glad bioshock wo over halo. Although halo is good and fun, bioshock was overall the better crafted game in my opinion, and was more of a work of art than a product.
• 
  0 thumbs!

  ConkerASkyJockey | December 10, 2007
  In my own personal opinion, Bioshock shouldn't had won "Best Game of the Year" award. I can agree it's a good game but I find Mass Effect already better.
  
  Halo winning the best multi-player award wasn't surprising. Although, I still think Warhawk could have been given credit as I find it a better game then Halo 3.
  
  Overall, the winners are pretty decent as some of them deserved there current award while some don't deserve it.
• 
  0 thumbs!

  Dark Prince Vegeta | December 10, 2007
  I think Assassin's Creed should've won Best Graphics as well. Bioshock does look amazing, but I think AC looks better.
• 
  0 thumbs!

  Hakashi | December 15, 2007
  Not surprised at half of those winners, especially BioShock