Subjectivity should be accepted not criticised, but that hasn't stopped fanboys from ripping into recent game awards handed out by Spike TV and GameTrailers, claiming all sorts of bias. Step forward Metacritic.com, which offers its awards based on nothing but review score aggregation. No arguments? Unlikely.

While some readers may deride the respectability of certain review sources listed on Metacritics pages, there’s little arguing with contributing numbers provided by IGN, GameSpot, GameSpy, Game Informer, Edge, 1UP, Play, and Games Radar.

Bearing that in mind, Metacritic has unveiled various "Best" and "Dud" games spread across a host of categories, which are as follows...
| More
Register as a member to subscribe comments.
  • 0
    black doom Dec 31, 07
    Super Mario Galaxy and Phantom Hourglass where great.
  • 0
    Zero and X Dec 31, 07
    Call of Duty 4 is a multi platform game, I dont think that should count as the best PS3 game
    • 0
      black doom Dec 31, 07
      But it rated highest overall didn't it? That would mean it was the PS3's best game, even if it did come out for other consoles. Unless others were tied with it.
  • 0
    Shadow of Death Dec 31, 07
    Yeah, I've heard of the DS Dud "Deal or no Deal" >_>

    Woulda liked to see a list of EXCLUSIVE games that rated high >_>
    • 0
      black doom Jan 1, 08
      That could have been great, too bad it didn't happen.

      They really should have included that.
  • 0
    Remino52 Dec 31, 07
    Black doom your first post is agreeable.Galaxy was great.

This news story is archived and is closed to comments now.